Canada Vs USA



The longest international rivalry in cricket, in fact in any sport is that between Canada and the USA, with the first match (won by Canada) played in 1844.

It has been continually reported, in Canada, that the earliest international athletic contest, of the modern era, was established in 1844 when Canada and the United States played at cricket at the Saint George's Club in New York for a wager of $1,000.00. It should be noted that in The Cricketer's Guide, (1858), it is recorded that The Canada match began in friendly encounters between the Toronto and Saint George's (New York) clubs in 1844. The Match first assumed its present godly proportions of Canada vs. the United States in 1853.

As with all matters related to cricket, there is always more than one version of events, but we prefer the American version of the first Canada vs. USA International as described by Das as in the following:

The match in 1844 at Bloomingdale in New York, came about because in 1843, a New York team had landed penniless in Toronto and were fully financed and entertained by their magnanimous hosts. In order to honor this Canadian gesture, the New Yorkers invited the Canadians to play in New York. The US team was drawn from several New York clubs, and also included players from the Philadelphia, DC, and Boston (the other centers of US cricket at the time). The Canadians, too, tried to come up with a representative team. All the posters and advertisements of the match from that period, which are available in cricket libraries, refer to a "Canadian vs. USA" match, not a New York vs. Toronto fixture. There were about 20,000 spectators at the match, and bets of around $120,000 (close to $1.5 million in todayÆs currency) were placed on the outcome. By any reckoning, therefore, this has to be recorded as an international fixture and a major one at that, surpassing many sporting events of that time.


SCORECARD: CANADA vs USA
First ever match at St George Cricket Club Ground, Manhattan, New York
September 24-25, 1844

Result: Canada won by 23 runs


Toss: USA    
Umpires: H Russel and Walker    


Canada 1st innings     Runs
D Winckworth run out   12
J Wilson   b Wright 0
Birch c Bage   5
GA Barber   b Wright 1
Sharpe   b Wright 12
GA Phillpotts lbw b Groom 1
JB Robinson lbw   1
HJ Maddock not out   7
Freeling c Dudson   12
French   b Groom 9
Thompson   b Wright 5
Extras (b 11, w 6)   17
Total (all out)   82


USA 1st innings     Runs
J Turner b Winckworth 7
G Wheathcroft b Winckworth 9
J Ticknor lbw 0
J Symes c Thompson 1
H Groom c Thompson 0
R Bage not out 1
R Ticknor b Thompson 5
S Wright c Barber 4
RN Tinson st Philpotts 14
S Dudson c Freeling 4
Wild b Winckworth 10
Extras (b 7, w 2) 9
Total (all out) 64


Canada 2nd innings     Runs
D Winckworth b Wright 14
J Wilson b Groom 0
Birch  c Turner 0
GA Barber  b Groom 3
Sharpe b Groom 5
GA Phillpotts b Wright 13
JB Robinson b Wright 4
HJ Maddock b groom 7
Freeling not out 7
French b Wright 0
Thompson lbw 3
Extras (w 7) 7
Total (all out) 63


USA 2nd innings     Runs
J Turner c Barber b Sharpe 14
J Ticknor b Sharpe 0
J Symes b Sharpe 11
H Groom b Winckworth 0
R Bage not out 5
R Ticknor b Sharpe 8
S Wright b French 3
RN Tinson lbw b Sharpe 0
S Dudson c Winckworth b Sharpe 0
Wild c Maddock 8
G Wheathcroft* absent -
Extras (b 3, w 6) 9
Total (all out) 58
*Wheatcroft failed to arrive in time to bat in 2nd innings


The competition finds itself much neglected going into the 21st Century. In 2002 the headline on the CCA wepage said it all. Canada vs USA match cancelled due to lack of sponsorship.


Canada Vs USA - update

USA v Canada, New York, September 24-25, 1844

The oldest international contest of them all

Canada 82 and 63 beat USA 64 and 58 by 23 runs

It is generally accepted that the match between USA v Canada in September 1844 was the first international cricket fixture. The first game between the two nations, played for a wager of US$ 1000, was watched by 10,000 spectators at the St George's Club at Bloomingdale Park in New York.

Those who dispute the 1844 date point to The Cricketer's Guide of 1858, where it is recorded that "The Canada match ... began in friendly encounters between the Toronto and St. George's (New York) Clubs .. in 1844. It first assumed its present goodly proportions of Canada v the United States in 1853." But most people are happy that the 1844 match was where international cricket started.

As with all matters related to cricket, there is always more than one side to a story. The American version of the first Canada v USA international is described by Deb Das as follows:-

"The match of 1844, at Bloomingdale Park in New York, came about because in 1843, a New York team had landed penniless in Toronto and were fully financed and entertained by their magnanimous hosts. In order to honor this Canadian gesture, the New Yorkers invited the Canadians to play in New York. The US team was drawn from several New York clubs, and also included players from Philadelphia, DC, and Boston (the other centers of US cricket at the time). The Canadians, too, tried to come up with a representative team. All the posters and advertisements of the match from that period, which are available in cricket libraries, refer to a Canada v USA match, not a New York v Toronto fixture.

"There were about 20,000 spectators at the match, and bets of around $120,000 (close to $1.5 million in today's currency) were placed on the outcome. By any reckoning, therefore, this has to be recorded as an international fixture - and a major one at that, surpassing many sporting events of that time."

The following Canadian version of the same event was written by Kevin Boller:-

"The match had taken place as the result of a hoax, perpetrated some four years earlier by a certain Mr. Phillpotts who had invited the St. Georges Cricket club of New York to visit Canada and play a friendly game against the Toronto Cricket Club on the northern shores of Lake Ontario. On the afternoon of August 28, 1840 eighteen travel- weary members of the St. George's Club turned up in Toronto following an exhausting journey through the state of New York by coach and across Lake Ontario by steamer only to discover that the members of the Toronto Cricket Club had no knowledge of any such cricket match.

"The sociable Mr. Phillpotts, who had originated the whole episode, could not be located, which of course, came as no big surprise to everyone involved. The officials of the Toronto Cricket Club felt most uncomfortable about the whole state of affairs and as a result a hastily called meeting was convened of members who could be rounded up on short notice. Following some earnest discussion, a challenge match was organized between the two clubs for a stake of fifty pounds ($250) a side.

"Despite the hurried arrangements a sizeable number of spectators turned out and the band of the 34th Regiment entertained the gathering. His Excellency the Governor of Upper Canada, Sir George Arthur added a regal touch to the occasion by putting in an appearance. Following the match which the New Yorkers won by 10 wickets, a gala dinner was held and judging by press accounts of the day a great time was had by all. Fortunately out of this confusion a rapport developed between the St. George's Club and the Toronto Cricket Club and as a result plans evolved for the historical encounter between the two countries at New York in 1844. The match was played for a stake of $1,000 on September 24-25 at the grounds of the St. George's Club. The Toronto Herald reported the crowd to be about 5000 and as much as $100,000 depended on the outcome".

© Wisden Cricinfo Ltd



ICC Intercontinental Cup, 2004 - United States of America v Canada

ICC Intercontinental Cup, 2004
United States of America v Canada
Brian Piccolo Park, Cooper City, Fort Lauderdale
28,29,30 May 2004 (3-day match)

Result: Canada won by 104 runs
Points: Canada 30.5, United States of America 15

Toss: Canada
Umpires: B Doctrove (WI) and N Malcolm (WI)
First-Class debuts: A Bagai, D Chumney, H Dhillon, Z Hussain, A Patel, E Sinnathamby, Z Surkari (Canada); Aijaz Ali, Z Amin, D Blake, Javed Nasir, M Johnson, HR Johnson, S Massiah, CA Reid (United States of America).
Match Referee: JJ Crowe (NZ)

Close of Play:

  • Day 1: Canada 221, United States of America 110/8 (Ajaz Ali 24*, Javed Nasir 0*; 34 overs)
  • Day 2: United States of America 136, Canada 145, United States of America 87/2 (M Johnson 37*, Massiah 25*; 23 overs)
    Canada 1st innings                                              R   M   B  4 6  D Chumney             c HR Johnson        b Amin               33  73  59  3 2  *JM Davison           run out (Reid/Lambert)                   84     113  7 3  Z Surkari             c M Johnson         b Javed Nasir         1   6  11  0 0  IS Billcliff          c Amin              b Javed Nasir         3  20  15  0 0  +A Bagai                                  b Amin                0   6   7  0 0  NA de Groot           c Massiah           b Blake              11  48  43  0 0  H Dhillon             c Ajaz Ali          b Lambert            69     148  6 2  Sunil Dhaniram        c HR Johnson        b Javed Nasir         0   3   2  0 0  Z Hussain             lbw                 b Javed Nasir         0  25  11  0 0  A Patel               not out                                   8  15  24  1 0  E Sinnathamby         c Blake             b Javed Nasir         2  18  16  0 0  Extras                (lb 1, b 1, w 2, nb 6)                   10  Total                 (all out, 73.5 overs)                   221    FoW: 1-57, 2-67, 3-69, 4-69, 5-106, 6-194,       7-194, 8-209, 9-209, 10-221.    Bowling                      O      M      R      W  HR Johnson                   8      1     25      0 (5nb)  Reid                         4      0     22      0  Amin                        20      7     35      2  Javed Nasir                 23.5    7     78      5 (1w)  Massiah                      2      0     11      0 (1nb)  Blake                        5      1     17      1  Lambert                     11      0     31      1 (1w)    United States of America 1st innings                            R   M   B  4 6  LC Romero             c Billcliff         b Davison            33 112  75  2 0  +M Johnson            lbw                 b Patel               0   2   1  0 0  *RW Staple            c Sinnathamby       b Davison            30  54  48  4 0  S Massiah             c Billcliff         b Davison             7  36  34  0 0  CA Reid               c Davison           b Dhaniram            4  11  13  0 0  CB Lambert            c Dhillon           b Davison             2  14   3  0 0  Ajaz Ali              c Hussain           b Davison            36  48  41  1 2  Z Amin                c de Groot          b Davison             2   3   4  0 0  D Blake               c de Groot          b Davison             0   1   1  0 0  Javed Nasir           not out                                  11  36  18  1 0  HR Johnson            c Hussain           b Davison             2   6   8  0 0  Extras                (b 5, nb 2, w 2)                          9  Total                 (all out, 40.4 overs)                   136    FoW: 1-1 (M Johnson), 2-43 (Staple),       3-64 (Massiah), 4-77 (Reid),       5-83 (Romero), 6-90 (Lambert),       7-92 (Amin), 8-92 (Blake),       9-134 (Ajaz Ali), 10-136 (HR Johnson).    Bowling                      O      M      R      W  Patel                        6      1     12      1  Sinnathamby                  3      0     11      0  (1w,1nb)  Hussain                      3      0     16      0  Davison                     14.4    2     61      8  (1w,1nb)  Dhaniram                    14      4     31      1    Canada 2nd innings                                              R   M   B  4 6  D Chumney             c M Johnson         b HR Johnson          0   5   6  0 0  NA de Groot           c M Johnson         b Reid                2  40  24  0 0  Z Surkari             c Blake             b Reid                0   2   4  0 0  IS Billcliff          c Reid              b Amin               23  64  56  2 1  +A Bagai              run out (Lambert/M Johnson)              20  92  74  0 0  H Dhillon             c M Johnson         b Amin                2  14  17  0 0  *JM Davison           c HR Johnson        b Staple              3  10   8  0 0  Sunil Dhaniram        not out                                  65 161 148  4 1  Z Hussain             c M Johnson         b Lambert             8  40  45  1 0  A Patel               c Staple            b Javed Nasir         7      50  1 0  E Sinnathamby         lbw                 b HR Johnson          1  13   9  0 0  Extras                (lb 1, b 4, nb 4, pen 5)                 14  Total                 (all out, 72.5 overs)                   145    FoW: 1-0 (Chumney), 2-1 (Surkari),       3-21 (de Groot), 4-41 (Billcliff),       5-45 (Dhillon), 6-54 (Davison),       7-63 (Bagai), 8-96 (Hussain),       9-131 (Patel), 10-145 (Sinnathamby).    Bowling                      O      M      R      W  HR Johnson                   7.5    2     24      2 (3nb)  Reid                         6      2     10      2 (1nb)  Javed Nasir                 13      3     24      1  Staple                      17      4     32      1  Amin                        19      7     20      2  Massiah                      3      0     12      0  Blake                        2      1      4      0  Lambert                      5      0      9      1    United States of America 2nd innings (target: 231 runs)         R   M   B  4 6  +M Johnson                                b Davison            41  76  70  3 2  LC Romero             c Bagai             b Hussain            14  34  25  0 1  *RW Staple            c Surkari           b Davison             1   2   4  0 0  S Massiah             c Dhaniram          b Davison            37  85  73  1 1  CA Reid               c Dhaniram          b Davison             2  18  15  0 0  CB Lambert            c Chumney           b Davison            11  77  41  0 1  Ajaz Ali              c sub (M Chaudhury) b Davison             4   2   2  1 0  Z Amin                c Chumney           b Davison             1   5   7  0 0  D Blake               c Billcliff         b Davison             0   1   3  0 0  Javed Nasir           c de Groot          b Davison             2   8   9  0 0  HR Johnson            not out                                   2  29  17  0 0  Extras                (b 8, lb 2, w 1)                         11  Total                 (all out, 44.2 overs)                   126    FoW: 1-37 (Romero), 2-38 (Staple),       3-93 (M Johnson), 4-105 (Reid),       5-107 (Massiah), 6-111 (Ajaz Ali),       7-112 (Amin), 8-112 (Blake),       9-114 (Javed Nasir), 10-126 (Lambert).    Bowling                      O      M      R      W  Davison                     21.2    3     76      9  Hussain                      7      2     15      1 (1w)  Dhaniram                    15      6     18      0  Sinnathamby                  1      0      7      0  

    • 12th Man: J Desai - USA, M Chaudhury - Canada
    • Scorers: Petra Pompey and Steve Bacchus
    • JM Davison (1) retired hurt on 28* from 66/1 to 106/5
    • Bonus points
    • 1st innings
    • USA 2.5 batting, 5 bowling
    • Can 4 batting, 5 bowling
    • 2nd Innings
    • USA 2.5 batting, 5 bowling
    • Canada 2.5 batting, 5 bowling



  • Match Reports

    Team Pages: United States of America, Canada.

    Ground Page: Brian Piccolo Park, Cooper City, Fort Lauderdale

    Canada Player Pages: D Chumney, JM Davison, Z Surkari, IS Billcliff, A Bagai, NA de Groot, H Dhillon, Sunil Dhaniram, Z Hussain, A Patel, E Sinnathamby.

    United States of America Player Pages: LC Romero, M Johnson, RW Staple, S Massiah, CA Reid, CB Lambert, Ajaz Ali, Z Amin, D Blake, Javed Nasir, HR Johnson.

    Match Officials' Pages: B Doctrove, N Malcolm, JJ Crowe.

    Contributed by the Management (help@cricinfo.com)  
    © Copyright Wisden CricInfo Ltd